DEFINITIVE REFERENCE FOR INDIAN CENT DIE VARIETIES


Home
Table of Contents
For Sale List
Numismatic Links
David's Numismatic blog




What are dies?


Blank steel Rods
Working Hub

Working Die
*The photos are copyright John A. Wexler and are being used here with his permission.

Dies are steel rods with a face the size of the coin they will strike.  All dies start out as a blank steel rod (Top Left) with a conical face.  These steel rods are given a conical face to facilitate metal flow when the blank steel rod is taken to a hubbing press to have a working hub (Top Center) impress its image on it.  Working hubs have grooves, which the arrows are pointing at in the center diagram, that align with the working die lugs, which the arrows are pointing at in the top right diagram.  These grooves and lugs insure alignment during hubbing, because multiple hubbings during the indian cent series were needed for a satisfactory design transfer.  In between hubbings, the working die would be annealed (heated) and rehubbed.  Working hubs have a face with the design of the coin in relief and exactly as it will look on struck coins.  When the working die has been fully hubbed by the working hub, its face will have a reverse and recessed image of what the struck coin will look like.

What are die varieties?

Die varieties are characteristics of an individual working die.  These characteristics can range from repunched dates, misplaced digits, doubled dies, die scratches and hubbing artifacts.  The aforementioned will be enumerated below with an explanation.  Bear in mind that whatever is recessed on a working die will be in relief on the struck coin.

1. Repunched Dates Prior to 1909, dates were individually impresed into the working dies by hand.  As such, alignment errors would occur and be corrected.  The result of the initial date punch impression would  leave remnants of the date as how it first appeared on the face of the working die.  Since the date and any repunching was sunk into the working die, it will be in relief on the coin.
2. Misplaced Digitis Digits that are too far away from the date are correctly referred to as misplaced digits.  This die variety occurs on the working die and can be attributed in most cases as date placement error.  Theese digits are commonly found in the denticles below the date, but do occur in the design.
3. Doubled Dies Doubled dies are actually misalignments that occur during the hubbing process.  Since there was more than one hubbing needed to impress a working die, misalignments would occur between the working hub and working die.  The result would be doubling on the working die.
4. Die Scratches Die scratches, or gouges for that matter, are scratches or gouges that occur on the face of a working die.  Since these are recessed on the working die face, they will appear in relief on a struck coin.  
5. Hubbing Artifacts Hubbing artifacts are remnants of the working hub that impressed the working die.  If a working hub has degraded to a point where there are broken letters, this will be transferred to the working die and the working die will show broken letters.

Attributing Individual Dies

In regards to this series, the entire design image is impressed into a working die from a working hub, with the exception of the date.  The dates were individually impressed into each working die with the exception of 1909.   As a result, there will be variances in the placement of the date and the above section of die varieties will help in desribing an individual dies.  So, we may use this fact to help us attribute, or identify individual dies.  By utilizing a simple geometric concept, we can measure date placement by construcintg a line from the left edge of the serif of the 1 and the left edge of the base of that 1 and extending it into the denticles below.  Where the line intersects in relation to a denticle is the date measurement and can be described as B(between denticles), LE(left edge of denticle),LH(left half of denticle), C(center of denticle), RH(right half of denticle) and RE(right edge of denticle).  Since two points define a line, the serif and base of the 1 satisfy that law and we have an accurate attribute for that particular die.  An illustration of this can be found here:  date placement .

Reverse die identification is not as precise, since the entire image ws impresed into a working die and there was nothing individually added, as was the case with the date on obverse working dies.  In this case, if the image was sunk deep into the working die, then elements close to the rim would touch or nearly do so.  These elements are the shield points and the first olive leaf.  If the image was not sunk too deeply, then these images would be farther away from the rim.  I rarely use this as an additional identifier for an obvere or reverse die variety, unless an obverse die variety is paired with two different reverses with no other die markers such as die cracks to differentiate the two.  Nevertheless, an illustration of this process can be found here:  Reverse Identification

Sometimes working dies will incur damge such as scratches, gouges, chips and etc. that also help in identifying particular dies.  Any type of mark on a working die will be transferred to a coin and will be in relief.  However, the absence of these identifiers leave us with only date placement and reverse hubbing depth to describe a particular die.  When I describe a die variety in this book, I will mention date placement and any other die marker present under the comment section of each variety.  In addition, a close-up of the date and macrophotography of the stated die variety.

So-Called Longacre Doubling

The term Longacre doubling is actually a misnomer for the the extra outlines seen on many indian cents.  Many new collectors will incorrectly identify these outlines as a doubled die, so I will try to shed some light on the subject.

These outlines are actually an artifact from the master die and are transferred to the working hubs and finally working dies  The degree at which these outlines on coins are seen is directly proportional to the hubbing depth that was imparted on the working hubs and working dies  Therefore, if hubbing depth was great, then outlines would be seen on the coins.  Conversely, if hubbing depth was lesser, then the presence of these outlines would be lessened or absent.  During 1886, Charles Barber designed a new obverse master hub from his galvano.  The galvano now included the legend, which was added to the master die prior to this change.  The master hub was then used to make a master die.  The manufacture of  this obverse master die is exactly where the extra outlines were eliminated.  In his article entitled "Extra Outlines", Rick Snow indicates the following:  "Apparently, Longacre did not want any field areas to effect the working hubs he was going to make, so he removed the metal from the field areas on the master die, being careful not to get too close to the letters and devices.  By doing this extra step, he created extra outlines."  Charles Barber's master die does not include this step, thus the outlines ended when longacre's master die disconttinued hubbing working dies.  The reverse hub longacre designed was never changed by Barber, so extra outlines remain on the reverses of many indian cents until the end of the series.

Die Numbering

The numbering system I use for this online reference is the same method that Jerry Fortin employs in his 'Definitive Resource for Liberty Seated Dime Variety Collectors".  I think it is a logical approach to the study of die pairs.

Die marriages for a particular date are dentoed by a number, starting with 1 and continuing with 2, 3, 4, and etc. for each consecutive die pair.  Die states for each variety will be denoted by a lower case letter next to the die marriage number.  For instance 1a, 1b and 1c all denote the same die pair, but each describe a different die state.  Die states are usually noted for die crack formations, cuds, clashes, and die polishing.  Where applicable,  a table will be available at the die variety page for a given date and will denote the die marriage number, as well as die stage letter.  In addition, a photograph of the obverse and reverse of the coin in each die state will be included in the table.  The die stage table is an important tool for conveying die state progression, whereas describing die states with just words seems inefficient
           

Obverse die for a particular die pair is denoted  with numbers, starting with 1 and coninuing onward for each observed die pair.  Die states for each obverse are listed as 1.2, 1.3 and etc.  Reverse die for a particular die pair is denoted with a capital letter, starting with A and continuing onward alphabetically for each observed die pair.  Die states for each reverse are listed as A.2, A.3 and etc.  

Scarcity Estimates

The universal rarity scale, which was first creatd by Q. David Bowers, will be utilized within this web book to estimate the total surviving examples of a given date, die pair, or die state.  Estimates are based on my 15 years experience wihin the indian cent series, as well as observations through auctions, publications and coin shows that I am able to attend.  Rarity estimates will be as accurate as possible and will be revised downward when more examples of a given die paring are located than initially estimated and upward when evidence supports a scacer estimate.  Of course, the tendency of estimate revisions are downward with the introduction of more examples of a given die pairing due to publication of this web book, longacre ledger and the fly-inclub.  

I have included the universal rarity scale below.  The third column was added by me to give an explanation, or example, of what the exact URS rating indicates in regards to the indian cent series.  Survival estimates for common date, tough date, etc. are derived from 'A Guide Book of Flying Eagle and Indian Head Cents' by Rick Snow.

The Universal Rarity Scale

URS RatingEstimated Examples KnownExplanation
URS-11Unique
URS-22Next to Unique
URS-33-4Nearly Unique
URS-45-8Very Rare
URS-59-16Rare
URS-617-32Extremely Scarce
URS-733-64Very Scarce
URS-865-124Scarce
URS-9125-249
URS-10250-499Unabridged Die Pairing Yield
URS-11500-999
URS-121,000-1,999
URS-132,000-3,999
URS-144,000-7,999Tough Date
URS-158,000-15,999
URS-1616,000-31,999Better Date
URS-1732,000-64,999
URS-1865,000-124,999
URS-19125,000-249,999
URS-20250,000-499,999Slightly Better Date
URS-21500,000-999,999
URS-221,000,000-1,999,999Common Date
URS-232,000,000-3,999,999Very Common Date